Mr Pizza's Pasta House

Nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 2325 Richmond Ave, Mr Pizza's Pasta House is much more than your average Italian eatery—it's a cherished local gem where the art of pizza-making and traditional Italian comfort food come together in perfect harmony. Specializing in both classic Italian and iconic pizza dishes, this cozy restaurant invites you to indulge your senses in a flavorful journey that never disappoints.

The menu is a delightful showcase of standout favorites that have captured the hearts and palates of the neighborhood. Imagine sinking your teeth into their creamy, luscious White Pizza or savoring the balanced zest of the Vodka Pizza, both boasting irresistibly melty cheeses and perfectly baked crusts. For those looking to explore beyond pizza, the Broccoli Stuffed Artichoke and the boldly flavored Buffalo Chicken Eggrolls offer a unique twist on classic Italian appetizers.

Salad enthusiasts can relish the fresh, crisp Tri-Color Salad that provides a refreshing respite, while pasta lovers are treated to hearty, soul-warming dishes like Pasta Meatballs and rich, cheesy Lasagne. The Arancini—golden fried risotto balls stuffed with oozy cheese—and the satisfying Stromboli further enhance the menu’s diversity, appealing to both traditionalists and adventurous diners alike.

One cannot forget the addictive appeal of Mr Pizza’s Antipasto Foccacia Pie, an imaginative blend of robust Italian flavors nestled on a crispy foccacia crust, or their signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice, which perfectly marries spicy and savory notes.

What elevates Mr Pizza's Pasta House beyond its delectable offerings is the warm and inviting atmosphere that wraps around every guest. Step inside to experience an ambiance that’s both stylish and comfortable, where striking Tiffany lamps cast a gentle glow beneath a striking red tiled ceiling—a setting praised for its unique and distinguished vibe. It’s the kind of place where you feel right at home, whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a relaxed dinner with family and friends.

From the moment you walk through the door, the friendly and attentive staff make you feel genuinely welcome. As Mia M shared, “The owner and staff are so genuinely pleasant, helpful, friendly, and hardworking,” creating a vibe that’s as comforting as the food itself. The speedy service and cheerful smiles, as noticed by Lui’s Clues and George Dgheim, add to a seamless dining experience that keeps guests coming back.

Mr Pizza's Pasta House doesn’t just serve meals—they craft moments filled with flavor, community, and warmth. Whether you’re craving a cheesy, perfectly balanced pizza slice after a long day or looking to dive into rich, satisfying pasta dishes, this is a Staten Island treasure that promises both quality and character in every bite.

For reservations or takeout, call +1 718-370-0102 and prepare to treat your taste buds to some of the best Italian dishes and pizza the New York borough has to offer.